
forums.noria.com
Message Boards
Car and Truck Lubrication
Coolant and engine oil. EG vs PG, is one less damaging?|
Go
![]() |
New
![]() |
Find
![]() |
Notify
![]() |
Tools
![]() |
Reply
![]() |
|
|
Bronze Member - 1 or more posts |
Found an old 2001 post suggesting EG coolant damages bearings at 0.5% by volume, whereas PG didn't cuase damage up to 8.0%
I haven't been able to confirm that, but would like to know. Recent oil analysis (22ppm potassium at 46k on oil) indicates a possible small intrusion of coolant into my engine oil. From a few posts here and elsewhere, it was suggested that EG damaged bearings at less than .4% by volume, but PG did not at up to 8%. I can find no substantiated proof of this. Besides searching, I have talked with Blackstone, Fleetguard, and Fleetguards oil analysis tech. None of them had any info that one was less damaging than the other. If I were sure, then I would switch to PG as a precaution, but hate to waste good coolant if no advantage. Anyone have any input on this? Preferably with some studies or sources I could refer to. Thanks Don |
||
|
|
Double Platinum Member - 100 or more posts |
Wear is somehow a miracle. It does not appear always to 100% just because one parameter is NOK. Sometimes this happens just at 2-5% of all cases. So, how do you know whith one single case if there is a general problem or not?
I am rather sure that you will not find a study proving this theory. What I can tell you is that you may get corrosion in your cooler by using the wrong coolant. A Potassium level in such a low range is in general no problem, but it might be a good idea to check your engine for leaks. |
|||
|
| Previous Topic | Next Topic | powered by eve community |
| Please Wait. Your request is being processed... |
|
forums.noria.com
Message Boards
Car and Truck Lubrication
Coolant and engine oil. EG vs PG, is one less damaging?
© 2006 Noria
Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
Guidelines
and Terms

